A heritage church from New Brunswick, sold in the late 1990s, has found a new purpose in Oklahoma City’s vibrant arts district. The Old Trinity Church, constructed in 1842, served as the sole Anglican church in Blackville, N.B., according to Shirley Underhill, who claims to be among the last individuals baptized in the church. Despite efforts to preserve the historic church as a memorial, financial constraints led to its sale and relocation. Underhill expressed joy at seeing the church revitalized.
Having been involved with the Old Trinity Church for more than forty years, Underhill participated in the restoration efforts following the church’s deconsecration, sale, and relocation. The site now features a monument honoring former church ministers and serves as a burial ground for cremated individuals.
Former Blackville resident David Underhill reminisced about the church hosting numerous weddings, including his sister’s ceremony. Additionally, he fondly recalled the community gathering at the skating rink behind the church. After being sold to a buyer in Oklahoma City, the church was dismantled and transported across the border in late 2000.
The church’s new owner, a photographer, transformed it into an art studio in Oklahoma City’s Paseo Art District. Over the years, the property changed hands, serving various roles like an art studio, wedding venue, private residence, and now back as an art studio. A plaque honoring its New Brunswick heritage remains on display in the kitchen.
Real estate agent Britta Thrift, who facilitated the recent sale of the property, highlighted the historical significance of the building and the unique challenges in pricing it. The property’s popularity due to personal connections with events like weddings and baby showers contributed to its quick sale.
Ernesto Sanchez, alongside artist Lin Sanchez, are the current owners of the building, now being used as Ernesto’s art studio. The couple, familiar with the Paseo Art District, found the space conducive to creativity and plan to welcome visitors by appointment and on select days, ensuring the old church continues to be accessible to those interested in visiting.
